‘All I Want for Christmas Is You’ Copyright Lawsuit Refiled Against Mariah Carey, Seeks $20 Million

Dessi Gomez

1 November 2023 at 3:58 pm·2-min read

Mariah Carey faces a lawsuit over the copyright for “All I Want For Christmas Is You” again as a previously withdrawn case has been refiled.

Country singer Andy Stone, who performs under the stage name Vince Vance with the band Vince Vance and the Valiants, refiled the suit against Carey, Sony Music Entertainment and Universal Music Group for copyright infringement along with plaintiff Troy Powers, who co-authored the band’s song of the same name. Stone seeks $20 million in damages.

Neither Carey nor Sony Music Entertainment has responded to the refiling. TheWrap has reached out to Carey’s reps for comment.

Vince Vance and the Valiants’ “All I Want For Christmas Is You” came out in 1989 and garnered “extensive airplay” during the 1993 Christmas season before Carey’s song appeared on her 1994 Christmas album, “Merry Christmas.”

General allegations in the refiled suit call Stone and Powers’ co-authored song “a country music hit” after it was released. The paperwork also claims the song “helped Vince Vance and the Valiants gain national prominence.” The band performed at the White House in April 1994, and they were invited back for a second performance in 1995.

Stone ended his previous suit last November. The former suit asked for $20 million in damages for copyright infringement, false association and unjust enrichment.

“Defendant Carey has capitalized on the success of her infringing work,” the paperwork reads.

The former case, Stone v Carey et al, involved an amended suit against the singer and her label Sony Music Entertainment that called Carey’s song a “derivative version” of Stone’s regarding the melody, harmonies, meter, rhythm and lyrics.

Pamela Chelin contributed to this report.

An earlier version of this story misstated the damages sought in each lawsuit. Those amounts have been corrected.

The post ‘All I Want for Christmas Is You’ Copyright Lawsuit Refiled Against Mariah Carey, Seeks $20 Million appeared first on TheWrap.

NextShark
16-year-old Chinese boy beat with iron rod on New Zealand bus
On Friday morning, during the Maori New Year public holiday, a 16-year-old teen named Jason was brutally attacked on an Auckland bus by a woman wielding an iron rod. The assailant, described as a Maori woman “more than 200 kilograms," hit Jason multiple times and stabbed him in the face, knocking out five of his teeth, on board the bus after having allegedly shouted "ch*nk" at him at Johns Lane stop. Man intervenes: A 75-year-old Chinese man, Penglai Qiuyue, intervened and managed to grab the weapon, though he was also injured in the process.
Malay Mail
Abused husky rescued after viral video, owner files police report demanding his dog back (VIDEO)
KUALA LUMPUR, JULY 3 — A viral video showing a man beating his dog, a husky, while his other, smaller dog cowered in a c...
Malay Mail
As AG stays silent, Rosmah presses on with bid to strike out money laundering and tax evasion charges
KUALA LUMPUR, July 4 — Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor's money laundering and tax evasion trial proceeded today despite the lac...
The Telegraph
Michelle Obama the only Biden alternative who would beat Trump
The only prospective candidate who could beat Donald Trump in the presidential election is Michelle Obama, according to a new poll.
HuffPost
Death Of Teenage Badminton Star Prompts Outrage Over Delayed Medical Response
Video from the incident shows tournament officials watching Chinese athlete Zhang Zhijie for around 40 seconds before medical help arrives.
Malay Mail
Tour bus driver in fatal Genting crash claims trial to reckless driving causing death, and having no valid licence
KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — S. Anand Kumar, the Malaysian man behind the wheel of the tour bus that overturned and killed two...
Malay Mail
Singapore’s new S$20,000 cash declaration rules: What Malaysians need to know
Singapore has implemented new regulations since May requiring all travellers to declare cash exceeding S$20,000 (RM69...
Malay Mail
In court, Mais and Hindu family agree man won’t be reburied according to Islamic rites; next-of-kin to inherit assets
KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — A court dispute between the Selangor Islamic Religious Council (Mais) and a Hindu family was sett...
People
Dua Lipa Goes Instagram Official with Boyfriend Callum Turner After Months of Romance Rumors
The pop singer posted a cozied-up photo with the British actor on Instagram from the Glastonbury Festival this past weekend
The Telegraph
The world must prepare for President Michelle Obama
The 2024 US Presidential race intensifies. Speculation abounds over potential replacements for President Joe Biden amid increasing pressure from his party and the media to step aside after a jaw-dropping, catastrophic debate against Donald Trump last week. Among the names circulating, a game-changer is emerging: Michelle Obama. Could this be America’s worst nightmare?
People
Jennifer Lopez Flaunts Her Abs in White Crop Top and Baggy Jeans During N.Y.C. Outing
Lopez was spotted wearing her wedding ring with the casual attire
The Telegraph
Hindu priest sexually abused hundreds of followers, High Court hears
A woman accusing a religious leader of exploiting and sexually abusing her told the High Court he has done it to “hundreds” of his followers over the last 40 years.
The Guardian
Video appears to show gang-rape of Afghan woman in a Taliban jail
Activist claims she was threatened with release of the footage in order to silence her, amid multiple reports of sexual violence inflicted upon imprisoned Afghan women
Bloomberg
These flight routes suffer the world’s worst turbulence
A series of incidents that left scores of airline passengers needing medical attention has shone a spotlight on the problem of severe in-flight turbulence.
The Telegraph
Martina Navratilova hits out at ‘regressive’ campaign featuring rugby players in lingerie
Martina Navratilova has led a backlash against a “regressive” campaign featuring Team GB’s Olympic rugby players in lingerie.
Malay Mail
What you should know about: Malaysia’s proposed ‘lemon law’ for cars
Malaysia is proposing a so-called “lemon law” that would provide vehicle buyers in the country more protection against f...
Entertainment Weekly
Victoria and David Beckham rewear purple wedding outfits to celebrate 25th anniversary: 'Look what we found'
The soccer star and Spice Girls singer married July 4, 1999.
Business Insider Video
Hong Kong Mafia (triad) member breaks down 12 HK Mafia scenes in movies and TV
Jimmy Tsui, a former member of the Sun Yee On triad in Hong Kong and Tung On in New York City's Chinatown, breaks down 12 Chinese organized-crime scenes in movies and TV shows based on realism. Tsui breaks down the accuracy of triad activities in Hong Kong and the United States, such as the money-laundering scenes in "Rush Hour 2," with Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker; "A Better Tomorrow," with Chow Yun-fat and Leslie Cheung; the human smuggling ring in "Lethal Weapon 4," with Jet Li, Mel Gibson, and Danny Glover; and the connection of triads with the nightclub and movie industries in Hong Kong in "Young and Dangerous 3." He explains the realism of triads dealing with law enforcement and other international criminal organizations, such as the Irish Mob in "The Departed," with Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, and Jack Nicholson; the tensions between the yakuza and the San Francisco triad in "War," with Jason Statham; the relationship between the Hong Kong police and the triads in "Infernal Affairs," starring Tony Leung and Andy Lau; and the interaction with motorcycle clubs in "Sons of Anarchy" S6E10. Tsui also looks at scenes in New York City's Chinatown, such as the rivalry between two Tong associations in "The Corruptor," with Mark Wahlberg and Chow Yun-fat; and the gambling-house scene in "Year of the Dragon." Tsui also explains the rituals and hierarchy of the triads, such as the initiation-ceremony scene in "Election" (2005) and the voting scene in "The Brothers Sun" E7, starring Michelle Yeoh. Tsui was involved with the Sun Yee On triad and Tung On in New York City's Chinatown for over 10 years. In 1985 in New York, he was arrested and charged with robbery and homicide with a $1.5 million bail. The case was dismissed and resulted in his transition into Sun Yee On in 1988. He was involved in karaoke bars, gambling houses, and various scams. After leaving the triads, Tsui got involved with Chinatown Gang Stories, a YouTube channel organized by Mike Moy, a former gang member and New York City Police Department officer. You can learn more about Jimmy Tsui's story here: https://www.youtube.com/@chinatowngangstories
HuffPost
Van Jones Reveals ‘Behind The Scenes’ Moves That Could End Biden Campaign
The CNN commentator detailed the “big conversation” taking place right now among Democratic insiders.
People
Victoria and David Beckham Slip Back into Their Iconic Purple Wedding Outfits to Celebrate 25th Anniversary
The couple got married on July 4, 1999

Latest stories