Whitehouse calls on Alito for info on ‘improper’ WSJ interview

Al Weaver
·2-min read

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), a top Senate Judiciary Committee member, is calling on Justice Samuel Alito to provide information about an interview he gave The Wall Street Journal on Supreme Court ethics, a request that comes after Alito declined to recuse himself from cases involving Jan. 6, 2021, and the 2020 election.

Whitehouse said the interview, in which Alito said there is “no provision in the Constitution” that gives Congress the authority to regulate the court, was “improper.” The interview was published in July, more than a month after ProPublica reported that the associate justice vacationed with a top GOP donor to Alaska for a fishing trip.

“The interview raised several problems,” Whitehouse said in a letter. “It thus appears that you offered an improper opinion regarding a question that might come before the Court; did so in the context of a known ongoing legal dispute involving that precise question; did so at the behest of an interviewer who as a lawyer represented a client in that ongoing dispute; and did so to the benefit of his client, your personal friend, and to the benefit of yourself, as a recipient of undisclosed gifts that are the subject of our investigation.”

“I note that the Supreme Court is the only place in all of government where issues of this nature have no place or means of investigation or resolution,” Whitehouse continued. “So far, my questions regarding these events seem to have disappeared into a black hole of indifference.”

The latest letter to the court comes as Democrats continue to be stonewalled by justices and Republicans in the fight over judicial ethics reform. The battle has only heated up after revelations that an upside-down flag flew over Alito’s home in Alexandria, Va., in the days surrounding Jan. 6 and President Biden’s inauguration.

Alito told Whitehouse and Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) in a recent letter that he will not recuse himself from a pair of cases the Court is set to rule on that involve Jan. 6, 2021, and the 2020 election. One of them will determine whether former President Trump is immune from prosecution.

In another communication between justices and the Court, Roberts told the pair that he will not meet with them to discuss the matter, saying it would be “inadvisable.”

Democrats have been unwilling to try to subpoena the chief justice over the ethics concerns surrounding the court because it is unclear whether they have the votes and that it would create tensions on the panel.

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • ‘Longkang otak’? FT minister moots system to track Malaysians working abroad to tackle brain drain

    KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Dr Zaliha Mustafa has reportedl...

  • The world must prepare for President Michelle Obama

    The 2024 US Presidential race intensifies. Speculation abounds over potential replacements for President Joe Biden amid increasing pressure from his party and the media to step aside after a jaw-dropping, catastrophic debate against Donald Trump last week. Among the names circulating, a game-changer is emerging: Michelle Obama. Could this be America’s worst nightmare?

  • Michelle Obama the only Biden alternative who would beat Trump

    The only prospective candidate who could beat Donald Trump in the presidential election is Michelle Obama, according to a new poll.

  • High Court says no to Najib’s judicial review bid over ‘house arrest’ call

    KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — The High Court today dismissed former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s bid to compel the f...

  • A growing club led by Xi and Putin to counter the US is adding a staunchly pro-Russia member

    A club of Eurasian countries spearheaded by China and Russia to advance their leaders’ vision of an alternative world order is set to expand again this week – this time adding a staunch Russian ally that has openly supported Moscow’s war on Ukraine.

  • China urges Philippines to punish killers of Chinese citizen

    China called on the Philippines to catch and severely punish the murderers of a Chinese citizen in a kidnapping case that prompted Beijing’s diplomatic intervention.

  • Court grants Muhyiddin’s request for temporary passport to attend granddaughter’s London graduation

    KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — The Sessions Court here today granted Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin’s application for a temporary inte...

  • Beijing is laughing at the West’s weakness

    Russian aggression in Ukraine poses a threat to world peace and stability. China provides material support for Russia’s actions. All this is entirely clear. In Beijing, immediately after a meeting with Xi Jinping in April this year, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said that “Russia would struggle to sustain its assault on Ukraine without China’s support”. This included selling huge quantities of machine tools and micro-electronics that would be used in the Russian defence industry.

  • Ivanka Trump breaks silence on father’s conviction in hush money case

    NEW YORK — Ivanka Trump broke her weekslong silence regarding her father’s recent hush money criminal conviction during a podcast appearance released Tuesday. The former White House staffer said the experience has been agonizing. “On a human level, it’s my father and I love him very much, so it’s painful to experience, but ultimately, I wish it didn’t have to be this way,” she said on “The Lex ...

  • Kristi Noem’s Shot At Kamala Harris Backfires Immediately

    The South Dakota governor, who once shot her puppy in a gravel pit, complained that the vice president isn’t relatable.

  • Russia's war-driven economy is so hot that the World Bank upgraded it to a 'high-income country'

    Russia's trade rebounded by nearly 7% last year, while activities in the financial sector and construction grew by 6.6% and 3.6% respectively.

  • The UK is about to get a new prime minister — someone Obama has been mentoring for months

    The leader of the Labour Party, Keir Starmer, has been mentored by Barack Obama. The relationship is likely to continue if Starmer wins the UK election.

  • Biden ‘seriously considering’ leaving election race

    Joe Biden has for the first time said that he is considering ending his presidential campaign, according to reports.

  • Chinese firms eye Morocco as way to cash in on US electric vehicle subsidies

    After the United States passed new subsidies designed to boost domestic electric vehicle production and cut into Beijing’s supply chain dominance, Chinese manufacturers began investing in an unlikely place: Morocco. In the rolling hills near Tangiers and in industrial parks near the Atlantic Ocean, they have announced plans for new factories to make parts for EVs that may qualify for $7,500 credits to car buyers in the United States. Similar investments have been announced in other countries that share free trade agreements with the United States, including South Korea and Mexico.

  • Israeli soldier killed in mall stabbing attack

    An Israeli soldier was killed and a second person was wounded in a stabbing in an Israeli mall on Wednesday that police said was a suspected terror attack. Israel's Ynet news site named the accused assailant, who was killed in the attack, as Joud Rabia from Nahaf, a town where members of Israel's Arab minority live. There was no claim of responsibility from any group, though militant group Palestinian Islamic Jihad in a post on the Telegram site described the attack as a "heroic operation."

  • Poland's Law and Justice says no to Orbán's Patriots and stays with Meloni's group in EU Parliament

    Poland's Law and Justice (PiS) had been courted by Hungary's Viktor Orbán to join his brand new "Patriots for Europe" alliance.

  • Newly confident opposition stages walkout as Modi address India’s new parliament

    Opposition lawmakers say they boycotted prime minister’s speech because he has ‘a habit of lying’

  • EU slaps Chinese electric cars with tariffs of up to 38%

    The European Union on Thursday slapped extra provisional duties of up to 38 percent on Chinese electric car imports because of Beijing's "unfair" support, a move that risks escalating tensions with Beijing.- Expected cut to imports - The United States has already hiked customs duties on Chinese electric cars to 100 percent, while Canada is considering similar action.

  • Israel 'evaluating' new Hamas 'ideas' on halting Gaza war

    The Hamas militant group said Wednesday it had sent new "ideas" to Qatari mediators aimed at ending the nearly nine-month Gaza war with Israel.Qatar-based Hamas political chief Ismail Haniyeh "made contact with the mediator brothers in Qatar and Egypt about the ideas that the movement is discussing with them with the aim of reaching an agreement", the group said in a statement. 

  • All change? Labour tipped to oust Tories at UK election

    Britain looks likely to see a change of government this week, swinging leftwards back to the centre ground and the Labour party after 14 years of right-wing Conservative rule.  Voters will elect a new parliament from 7:00 am (0600 GMT) on Thursday, with predictions of a landslide Labour win that would make Keir Starmer prime minister -- 100 years after Ramsay MacDonald became the party's first. "There is more chance of lightning striking twice in the same place... than Rishi Sunak remaining as prime minister," Britain's pre-eminent political polling expert John Curtice told the BBC on Tuesday.Starmer and Conservative leader Sunak have been criss-crossing the country in the final days of a largely lacklustre campaign to try to win over wavering voters.  Many people appear to have long made up their minds, however, with focus on little else other than whether Labour's consistent 20-point lead in the polls for the last two years will translate into a record majority. Prime Minister Sunak on Tuesday insisted that he is "fighting for every vote till the last moment of the campaign", drawing hope from England's last-gasp win in the European football championships.  "It's not over until it's over," Sunak wrote on social media on Sunday night after England's footballers scored a stoppage-time equaliser against Slovakia and then an extra-time winner.Starmer, a staunch Arsenal fan who still plays five-a-side football at 61, is also calling on his team to play until the final whistle, with fears that talk of a Labour "supermajority" could hit turn-out.- Growth -Sunak and the Tories -- another name for the Conservatives -- have been going all out to play upon people's fears, warning of tax rises and weaker national security if they are voted out, in what Labour sees as a desperate last-stand to cling on to power.But in a sign the political landscape has already shifted, it was Starmer, not Sunak, whose views were sought in the aftermath of the far-right win in the first round of the French general election.He has also been asked how he, as the leader of a "progressive" centre-left party, would deal with the possible return of Donald Trump as US president later this year.Attention in the British media is meanwhile mostly on what a Starmer government would look like when the results for the 650-seat parliament start dropping from about 2230 GMT on Thursday into Friday morning.Thursday's vote is Britain's first July election since 1945, when Labour under Clement Attlee defeated the Conservatives of World War II leader Winston Churchill, ushering in a period of transformational social change.Attlee's government created the modern welfare state, including the National Health Service, Britain's most cherished institution after the royal family. Starmer's "change" agenda is not so radical this time around and promises cautious management of the country's economy, as part of a long-term growth plan that includes nursing battered public services back to health."The most important thing is growing the economy and wealth creation," he told The Times in an interview published on Tuesday. "You can talk about public services but if you haven't got your economy working then you can't do that."- 'Run out of road' -With an air of inevitability about a Labour win, Starmer and his colleagues are facing mounting calls and growing expectations to change Britain's flagging fortunes for the better.Economists say anaemic growth should be addressed. Pro-Europeans want Brexit reversed. Everyone wants an end to the sustained squeeze on their finances over the last decade and a half that has tipped more people into poverty."In 2010, when the Conservatives came to power, the UK had 35 foodbanks. Now there are 2,600," Gordon Brown, Labour's last prime minister, wrote in the Daily Mirror on Tuesday.Others want a return of political integrity and stability after a chaotic period of five prime ministers, a succession of scandals and ideological infighting between centrists and right-wingers that shows no sign of abating. Starmer -- the working-class son of a tool maker and a nurse -- has none of the political charisma or popularity of former leader Tony Blair when he ended 18 years of Tory rule in a wave of optimism in 1997. But the former human rights lawyer and chief public prosecutor stands to gain from a country fed up with the Tories, and a feeling of decline rather than improvement."The Conservatives have run out of road. Labour must be given a chance to govern," said a Financial Times editorial Monday.phz/har/bc