Old video shows SA president rejecting Trump land grab claims in 2018, not 2025
Tendai DUBE / AFP South Africa
·5-min read
A video claiming to show South African President Cyril Ramaphosa “firing back” at his US counterpart Donald Trump for his recent accusations about land “confiscations” in the African country is being widely circulated online. But the video is six years old; it was recorded when Ramaphosa rejected similar claims by Trump in 2018.
“South African President Cyril Ramaphosa: ‘I don’t know what Donald Trump has to do with South African land. South Africa does not belong to Donald Trump. He must leave us alone. Stay out of our issues’ (sic),” wrote an X user who shared the video on February 3, 2025.
Screenshot of the misleading X post, taken on February 5, 2025
The pixelated, two-minute clip circulating online shows Ramaphosa standing behind a podium.
ADVERTISEMENT
“South Africa is our land. South Africa belongs to all the people who live here in South Africa. It does not belong to Donald Trump. He can keep his America,” Ramaphosa says in the video, adding the country will find solutions to its problems without Trump.
Similar misleading claims were shared thousands of times on multiple platforms including X, Facebook and TikTok.
The posts began circulating after Trump announced on February 2, 2025, that he was cutting off all future funding to South Africa for “confiscating” land and “treating certain classes of people very badly” (archived here).
South Africa responded to the accusations, but the Ramaphosa video in question dates back to Trump’s first term in office.
2018 video
A reverse image search using the video verification tool InVID-WeVerify revealed that the footage has been online since 2018.
ADVERTISEMENT
Among the results was a news report uploaded to YouTube by South Africa’s state broadcaster SABC on August 26, 2018. Captioned “Pres Ramaphosa hits back at Trump”, the bulletin covered remarks made by Ramaphosa after Trump entered the fray on land rights and farm murders in South Africa days earlier.
Trump, less than two years into his first term as president, tweeted on August 23, 2018, that he had called on his Secretary of State to look into South African land and farm seizures and the killing of farmers (archived here).
I have asked Secretary of State @SecPompeo to closely study the South Africa land and farm seizures and expropriations and the large scale killing of farmers. “South African Government is now seizing land from white farmers.” @TuckerCarlson@FoxNews
“I don’t know what Donald Trump has to do with South African land because he has never been here. He must keep his America. We will keep our South Africa; that is what he must do. South Africa is our land,” Ramaphosa said at the time (archived here).
A comparison between the broadcast footage from 2018 and the clip circulating in 2025 shows Ramaphosa wearing the same striped tie and standing in front of the identical backdrop.
Screenshot comparison of the 2018 video on YouTube (left) and the video circulating in misleading claims in 2025, taken on February 5, 2025
At the time, AFP Fact Check debunked numerous claims about this incident, including a viral fabricated tweet claiming that Ramaphosa said he would send his police minister to investigate US mass shootings.
2025 Expropriation Bill
The land issue in South Africa has long been divisive, with efforts to redress the inequality of white-rule drawing criticism from conservatives including South Africa-born Elon Musk, a powerful Trump adviser (archived here).
ADVERTISEMENT
In the latest showdown, South Africa’s official response to Trump’s allegations on February 3, 2025, was that no land had been confiscated (archived here).
“South Africa is a constitutional democracy that is deeply rooted in the rule of law, justice and equality,” Ramaphosa said on X.
Ramaphosa signed a bill in January 2025 stipulating that the government may, in certain circumstances, offer "nil compensation" for property it decides to expropriate in the public interest (archived here).
The bill has reignited fears of a crisis similar to the post-independence white-owned farm seizures in Zimbabwe.
However, Ramaphosa said the newly adopted Expropriation Act “is not a confiscation instrument” but a legal process that “ensures public access to land in an equitable and just manner as guided by the constitution”.
South Africa is a constitutional democracy that is deeply rooted in the rule of law, justice and equality. The South African government has not confiscated any land.
The recently adopted Expropriation Act is not a confiscation instrument, but a constitutionally mandated legal…
Ramaphosa added that South Africa receives no significant US funding except for the USAID programme for AIDS relief, PEPFAR.
South Africa is one of the largest recipients of funds from PEPFAR, a project launched in 2003 and now paused by Trump’s 90-day funding freeze on Washington's foreign aid (archived here).
Ramaphosa said he was willing to engage with the Trump administration over “land reform policy and issues of bilateral interest”.
“We are certain that out of those engagements, we will share a better and common understanding over these matters,” said Ramaphosa.
South Africa’s ruling party, the African National Congress, has since criticised AfriForum — a minority rights organisation for Afrikaners — for its “misinformation campaign” on land reform, which it believes influenced Trump (archived here).
.@afriforum will officially request the USA to directly punish senior ANC leaders and not the people of South Africa.
We, as ordinary citizens, are already being punished by a hostile and foolish government and @PresidencyZA in South Africa and do not want to be punished as… https://t.co/LoGJUiWfjy
President Trump on Sunday said he was losing patience with the ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas after seeing footage of the Palestinian militant group release Israeli hostages over the weekend, whose appearance he compared to Holocaust survivors. Trump's reaction to seeing images of the three hostages, who appeared gaunt upon their release on Saturday, brought fresh uncertainty over the deal's fate before all remaining 76 hostages are freed and came days after the president called for the removal of Palestinians from the enclave and for the U.S. to take control of it.
President Donald Trump said he will announce on Monday that the United States will impose 25% tariffs on all steel and aluminum imports, including from Canada and Mexico, as well as other import duties later in the week. “Any steel coming into the United States is going to have a 25% tariff,” he told reporters Sunday on Air Force One as he flew from Florida to New Orleans to attend the Super Bowl. When asked about aluminum, he responded, “aluminum, too” will be subject to the trade penalties.
Widespread anti-regime protests erupted across Iran on Sunday night as the Islamic Republic marked its 46th anniversary amid growing anger towards the clerics in power.
Vladimir Putin has an obvious advantage in manpower three years into the war in Ukraine, but even Ukrainian soldiers who have lost a leg push to return to the front lines as soon as they recover. Ukraine’s unbroken defenders say they would crawl into battle to defend their country if they have to. “You can lose a limb, but you can’t lose your dignity,” said Hulk, the call sign of the chief sergeant of the 1st Battalion of the Achilles 429th Separate Unmanned Systems Regiment. (Like most Ukrainia
A 19-year-old acolyte of Elon Musk known online as “Big Balls” has taken on new roles as a senior adviser at the State Department and at the Department of Homeland Security, raising concerns among some diplomats and others about his potential access to sensitive information and the growing reach of his tech billionaire boss into America’s diplomatic apparatus, said U.S. officials familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss a sensitive issue. Edward Coristine, who
In the 20 days since Donald Trump took office, he has unleashed a whirlwind of activity designed to cut government spending and slash the federal workforce. According to his pre-Super Bowl interview on Fox News, the campaign won’t stop anytime soon. While speaking to Fox News anchor Bret Baier Sunday ahead of Super Bowl LIX, …
The acting head of the federal agency responsible for responding to disasters said Monday that he’s suspending payments sent to New York City to house migrants and that staff who made them will be held accountable, after Elon Musk blasted the transactions on his social media platform. Musk, who as head of the Department of Government Efficiency has consolidated control over much of the federal government and is working to cut costs and shrink the workforce, posted on X that his team “just discovered that FEMA sent $59M LAST WEEK to luxury hotels in New York City to house illegal migrants.” Cameron Hamilton, acting administrator of the Federal Emergency Management Agency, reposted Musk’s comments and said the payments were suspended as of Sunday.
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on Monday the United States is walking away from “dumb” foreign aid, not from foreign aid entirely. “We’re not walking away from foreign aid,” Rubio said in an interview on SiriusXM’s “The David Webb Show” with guest host Scott Jennings. “We are walking away from foreign aid that’s dumb,…
An explosive report by the Washington Post alleges that the Trump’s administration is weeding out candidates for top intelligence and law enforcement jobs by asking if the Jan. 6 Capitol riot was an “inside job” and if the 2020 election was “stolen.” Those looking to apply to top national security positions with the administration are allegedly facing additional questions that test their loyalty to Trump. These questions seem quite tailored to determine candidates’ inclinations on the president’
Iran’s threat to assassinate President Donald Trump during the 2024 campaign led his team to take extreme precautions, which included riding on a decoy plane to throw off would-be pursuers. After law enforcement told Trump that Iran had snuck operatives into the country who had access to surface-to-air missiles, the president’s team worried that his easily recognizable private jet, “Trump Force One,” might make him an easy target during takeoff or landing. Concerns only grew after a failed attem
The families of the three Israeli hostages released Saturday have spoken out about their loved ones’ ordeal in Hamas captivity, saying they hope their suffering provides impetus to efforts to free all those still in Gaza as soon as possible.
Elon Musk demanded the impeachment of the federal judge who blocked his federal spending task force from accessing the payment systems at the Treasury Department. “A corrupt judge protecting corruption,” Musk tweeted in the early hours of Sunday morning. “He needs to be impeached NOW!” U.S. District Judge Paul Engelmayer ruled Saturday that special government employees and officials outside of the Treasury ought to be prohibited from accessing systems that contain sensitive information, effectiv
