Mikel Arteta knows why Arsenal suffered title agony – here’s what must come next

Arsenal have had worse days since Mikel Arteta took over, and certainly had worse seasons, but it has been rare to see the Basque as dejected as this. He looked more defeated than his team.

Usually keen to use any media appearance as a message to his players, Arteta this time looked like he would rather be anywhere other than his post-match press conference following the 3-0 home defeat to Brighton. Answers were mumbled. Comments were unclear.

Within it all, though, there was one line that stood out.

“If the team can show that face as well, there are things that have to be addressed.”

Put more bluntly, there will be changes, and not just squad improvements.

This was a team that had lost their drive, and consequently their edge. Arteta insisted that Manchester City’s earlier 3-0 win over Everton should not have affected his side but it was difficult not to think that that had been the case.

The manager is also entitled to be critical of his team for losing concentration. That’s how you start stamping out such a mentality and improving the team further.

He knows it will feed into wider criticism of him and the team. Some of it will be fair. It can be said Arsenal weren’t up to the required level, either as a team or in a psychological sense. A harsher description of their collapse is that they “bottled it”.

They probably did, especially if the base description of that overused phrase is mental pressure affecting performance levels.

Arsenal players look dejected following the final whistle (PA)
Arsenal players look dejected following the final whistle (PA)

It’s also true that Arsenal drastically over-performed this season, and that they can be proud of their efforts. Arteta said as much himself.

“You have to do a lot of good things, incredible things, to be second in this league, and we’ve done that.”

The reality is they have done more than expected. Had Arteta been told in August that Arsenal would run Manchester City to the final two weeks of the season, and with two games still to play have exceeded the points totals of all but four of Arsene Wenger’s seasons in charge, most people would have considered it preposterous. It points to the level of the job he’s done.

It is an unfashionable perspective after such a chastening defeat, but, if you stand back, this is really a very young side that has pushed itself to its outer limits and couldn’t give any more. Though the Gunners may not enjoy the comparison with their north London rivals, it happened to Mauricio Pochettino’s Tottenham Hotspur in 2015/16.

Arsenal can take heart from the fact that Spurs managed 86 points in the following campaign – a Premier League record for the club – because they were clearly a work in progress.

It is similar with Arsenal here. They might have given all they could this season, but there is surely more to come. The true value of this campaign may be in highlighting to Arteta exactly where his team is short – and to use that knowledge to go one step further in the future.

Mikel Arteta has sent out a warning to Arsenal’s players (PA)
Mikel Arteta has sent out a warning to Arsenal’s players (PA)

He has seen they lack depth overall, but also in key areas. While the variety of forwards means they can weather the loss of Gabriel Jesus, it doesn’t look like they can do similar with William Saliba and Martin Odegaard. They also need another strong midfielder.

That is considerable work to do for a team that has so far got 82 points after 36 games. If they get two more, they will have beaten all of Wenger’s sides bar the two title-winners of 2002 and 2004.

Many will point to a different context, and how the threshold of the league has been raised but that should be part of the discussion here. Many will also insist that the charges against City should be mentioned, although it might be a long time until the outcome of that is known.

Either way, the high threshold should really be more central to discussion than any talk of “bottling it”.

Really, it is an absurd situation that 80-plus points is not enough to win a league. It warrants grander debates than just unthinking declarations about how competitive the Premier League is. It has come from a growing financial gap since the early 2000s that has now been taken to extremes by the Abu Dhabi project at Manchester City.

You need at least 85 points to properly challenge Pep Guardiola’s and probably over 90 – if not even higher – to beat them. This is immensely demanding. Arsenal were the first club to reach 43 points after 16 games and not win the title.

The default position at the start of any season is that City under Guardiola will win the title.

In the end, they went on the unstoppable run everyone expected. Arsenal literally couldn’t compete against that, despite their own version early on. At least this season.

It has at least served to show what Arteta requires. Arsenal are also one of few clubs that at least have the resources and size to sustain something like a challenge over a medium-term spell. This is central to sizeable summer ambitions, that involve a higher class of player.

Arteta wants at least four. He needs that.

He doesn’t need to be too critical of this team, though. They have done all they can, and more than almost anyone expected.