Malaysia plans to privatize MRSM public boarding schools for rich folks, but should they?
The Majlis Amanah Rakyat (MARA) is a government agency in Malaysia that was established on Mar. 1, 1966, as a part of the Rural and National Development Ministry. Its purpose is to assist, educate, and mentor Bumiputra (Malays and other indigenous Malaysians) in the fields of industry and commerce.
MARA manages multiple boarding schools and the University of Kuala Lumpur, which is a technical university spread across several campuses.
The boarding schools are known as Maktab Rendah Sains MARA (MARA Junior Science Colleges or MRSMs), and they are supervised by MARA’s Education and Training (Secondary) Department. Their primary objective is to train Bumiputra students with the potential to excel in the fields of science and technology.
The establishment of MARA aimed to enhance the status of Bumiputeras and elevate their standard of living by providing them with education and economic prospects to create wealth.
Regardless, MARA has been open to Bumiputeras from all income brackets, as well as non-Bumis, with the latter having a 10% quota.
However, the government recently mulled the idea of building a separate and privatized MRSM for students from middle to high-income backgrounds.
Ahmad Zahid, who is also the Rural and Regional Minister, said applications to enrol in MRSM had exceeded 300% of its capacity.
“We are conducting feasibility studies to determine the number of students who are academically qualified to enrol in MRSM but due to their parents’ income bracket, they are not eligible, especially those in the M40 and T20 groups, as the priority (for entry) is for those from the B40 group,” he said.
There was too much demand, he added, from MRSM alumni who wished for their children to enrol in MRSM, but their income made them ineligible.
But what do Malaysians have to say about this?
Orang kaya sepatutnya tak masuk MRSM. Ada banyak private & international school untuk mereka, yang boleh beri pendidikan berkualiti.
Kalau orang kaya ambil slot MRSM, anak orang miskin yang bijak pandai nak ke mana? Sekolah private?https://t.co/Lu9zTggVvL— Roman Akramovich (@SyedAkramin) March 20, 2023
Satu lg aku xfhm kenapa org kaya sibuk nk biasiswa???you can afford it why you took the chances that are for poor students
— fira met svt
(@firachan627) March 27, 2023
I remember my dad told me “Sometimes these “rich” when they have a little extra money and they want big houses, big cars, big lifestyle but when it comes to their children’s education suddenly no budget. It’s all about priorities and living within your means, plan for future”. https://t.co/2xsjDOtKCG
— Ziq (@itsmejaziq) March 21, 2023
Someone argued that they only want a separate "elite school" for the kaya.
So you're encouraging elitism under the banner of something meant to help the less fortunate one?
Apa beza this and sekolah private?
Kau nak cekau resources MRSM jugak ke? https://t.co/HwEh8Eqd4a— Ariff, UniSlam ‘23 Finalist (@aaron_ariff) March 21, 2023
Hari demi hari hak orang miskin dirampas. https://t.co/wVivEUOlJb
— . (@blupbluplols) March 21, 2023
Ini soal akses pendidikan, MRSM sepatutnya fokus kepada anak-anak luar bandar, miskin yang tidak berpeluang untuk mendapatkan tuisyen tambahan. Orang kaya mampu untuk hantar anak mereka ke pusat tuisyen atau private tutor. Tak adil bila MARA lari jauh dari matlamat asal. https://t.co/Ds8vLZj8rj pic.twitter.com/iVh4IaRVHX
— Danial Jafri
(@danialljafri) March 21, 2023
While most of those on Twitter disagree with the move (as expected), some argued that the rich and poor should not be segregated when it comes to education.
Others theorized that the institution needs students from financially comfortable backgrounds as their parents would be able to donate in large amounts to MARA.
Let intelligent people be together REGARDLESS IF YOURE RICH OR NOT
poor people have things to learn from rich people and rich people have things to learn from poor people https://t.co/QAHKpPBefS— Tira (@hyuneenini) March 21, 2023
sad truth but mrsm needs anak orang kaya solely for monetary donations. https://t.co/S3Dqs6JmDN
— sekutlutot (@cicahkofi) March 21, 2023
Sebenarnya benda ni sekolah pon untung. Bila parents kaya hantar anak situ, time tu la sekolah nak perah duit kaw kaw dari golongan kaya ni. Dapat pulak yang pemurah, suka bagi sumbangan. Lagi diorang suka.
Morally wrong tapi tula, apa je yang adil dekat dunia ni https://t.co/S0yLIDoJIK— muja (@aidmujahid_) March 21, 2023
Youre denying intelligent kids who happen to be born in to rich families https://t.co/ZdvW7bkw8h
— dazeadoll (@dazea) March 20, 2023
If anything, MARA should stick to its original mission of providing education to the poor.
This is because the school system was set up with the specific purpose of bridging the gap between students from different socio-economic backgrounds. By providing affordable education to students from low-income families, MARA is helping to ensure that talented and hardworking students are not denied the opportunity to fulfill their potential due to financial constraints.
Furthermore, by maintaining its focus on providing education to the poor, the institution is helping to address the issue of inequality in Malaysia. Education is a powerful tool that can help to break the cycle of poverty and provide opportunities for upward mobility.