Hong Kong electoral changes: ‘small group of people’ to make up powerful vetting committee

Gary Cheung
·5-min read

A powerful new committee that will vet candidates for Hong Kong’s most important elections will be kept to fewer than 10 people under a drastic overhaul of the political system by Beijing, the Post has learned.

The committee would have an odd number of people and the chairman would act as the tiebreaker, said a source close to the two days of talks by China’s top legislative body that began in the capital on Monday.

To further ensure only “patriots” were running Hong Kong after the political turmoil of the past few years, the National People’s Congress (NPC) Standing Committee was also leaning towards adopting a stringent threshold for nominating candidates for the Legislative Council elections, the insider revealed.

Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.

It was understood the hopefuls could be required to secure nominations from all of the Election Committee’s five sectors representing various professions, organisations and sections of society, which would pose a formidable obstacle for the opposition camp in fielding candidates given the new fifth sector was to be filled by Beijing loyalists from “national organisations”.

Under the resolution endorsed by the NPC on March 11, the “candidates’ qualification review committee” would be responsible for ensuring anyone running for chief executive, the Legislative Council or the Election Committee itself posed no threat to national security.

The source said the Committee for Safeguarding National Security, chaired by the chief executive, and Beijing’s national security office in Hong Kong would advise the group. Both groups were established under the national security law that Beijing decreed for Hong Kong in June last year.

“The gatekeeping vetting committee will be a very small group of people,” the insider said. “The committee will be odd numbered as the chairman will be the tiebreaker.”

Lau Siu-kai, vice-president of semi-official Chinese Association of Hong Kong and Macau Studies, agreed that a committee of fewer than 10 people and kept to an odd number would be the “most efficient” to resolve controversies.

“[The committee] is expected to function in the form of a small working group to make decisions on the qualifications, which cannot be challenged by local courts,” he said. “This is how it can protect the national security most effectively.”

Lau also believed that national security officers would take up a crucial role in the committee to examine the background of potential candidates.

What we still don’t know about coming changes to Hong Kong’s election system

Xinhua reported that 167 members of the standing committee attended the meeting and scrutinised the proposed changes to annexes I and II of the Basic Law, which stipulated the rules for the city’s chief executive and Legco elections, respectively. Shen Chunyao, director of the body’s Legislative Affairs Commission, explained the drafts to the lawmakers.

Under the NPC resolution, the 1,200-strong Election Committee responsible for picking the chief executive will be expanded by 300 members to further reinforce the pro-establishment camp’s dominance of the body.

The committee will be empowered to nominate all Legco candidates, as well as to elect a “relatively large proportion” of its members, who will number 90 seats, up from the current 70.

Multiple sources have said the standing committee would make the Election Committee the strongest force in the revamped Legco, with 40 seats, while the number of seats returned by geographical constituencies would be slashed from 35 to 20. The number of seats for functional constituencies, which are mostly trade-based interest groups, would be reduced from 35 to 30.

Under previously released details, chief executive hopefuls will face a higher nomination threshold than before.

In the past, they had to obtain nominations from any 150 members of the Election Committee to qualify. Going forward, while would-be candidates must still secure backing from 188, or an eighth of the 1,500 members, they must also be nominated by at least 15 members from each of the five sectors.

As Hong Kong electoral overhaul is finalised, observers expect Beijing to ‘go as far as it can’

Asked whether lawmakers would also need to secure nominations from all five sectors, Tam Yiu-chung said in an exclusive interview published by the Post on Friday that it should be lower than that for the chief executive.

“Rather than 15 nominations [from each of the five sectors], can it be three or five? Rather than getting nominations from all five sectors, can it be three or two sectors only?”

The source familiar with the overhaul also said on Monday the standing committee’s decision would not provide all the answers and details for the city’s political overhaul, and the Hong Kong government must follow up and complete the local legislative work under a tight timetable.

“The decision will not answer all the questions. It will provide guidelines on matters such as the composition of the Election Committee and Legco. But the Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Bureau will need to work out more details and finalise them with Legco,” the insider said.

Legco, now operating without an opposition, is expected to finish scrutinising the amendments by mid-July, so polls for the Election Committee, Legco and chief executive can be held in September, December and March, respectively.

The chief executive was also expected to lead a large-scale campaign to explain to the city why Beijing is overhauling its electoral system.


More from South China Morning Post:

This article Hong Kong electoral changes: ‘small group of people’ to make up powerful vetting committee first appeared on South China Morning Post

For the latest news from the South China Morning Post download our mobile app. Copyright 2021.