Calls for Biden replacement ‘foolhardy nonsense’: Forecasting pioneer

Lauren Sforza
·2-min read

A notable elections forecaster said recently that the calls to replace President Biden following last Thursday night’s debate performance are “foolhardy nonsense.”

Allan Lichtman, a historian who has successfully predicted the outcome of nine of the last 10 presidential elections, dismissed the calls to boot Biden from the ballot, telling CNN’s Abby Phillip it would be a “huge mistake” to replace Biden on the ballot.

“So, this is all foolhardy nonsense. The same pundits and pollsters who led us down the primrose path in 2016 are giving the Democrats horrible advice. This proves what I’ve been saying for years,” he said Friday.

“Republicans have no principles. Democrats have no spine. Republicans are sticking with a blatant liar who lied for every one minute and 20 seconds of that debate. Donald Trump put out a lie,” he continued.

Some Democrats and numerous major media outlets have called on Biden to step down from the race after a lackluster showing at the debate.

The Biden campaign and the White House have been working to quell concerns over Biden’s debate showing in recent days, emphasizing that the president will not be stepping down from the ballot. The campaign released an ad Monday arguing Biden can do the job amid calls to drop out.

Lichtman suggested during the CNN appearance that Biden can move past his debate performance.

“And by the way, lies stick. Debate performances can be overcome. And now the first sign of, you know, adversity, the spineless Democrats want to throw under the bus their own incumbent president. My goodness,” Lichtman said.

Lichtman also said that while he does not have a final prediction yet as to who will win the race, debates do not have any significant impact on the outcome. He added that Democrats need to put forward Biden to have a chance of winning the race, based on his model of 13 criteria.

“Debates are not predictive of outcomes. Hillary Clinton won all three debates, still lost. John Kerry won all the debates, still lost. Barack Obama got trounced 72 to 20 percent in the poll, worse than Biden, and went on to win. That’s why we rely on the 13 keys, which tap into the structure of how elections really work,” he said.

“And they show that Democrats’ really only chance to win, contrary to everything you’ve heard, is with Biden running. Look at the incumbency key. Biden checks that off. The contest key, he checks that off. He was uncontested,” he added. “It takes six keys to count out the White House party.”

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Michelle Obama the only Biden alternative who would beat Trump

    The only prospective candidate who could beat Donald Trump in the presidential election is Michelle Obama, according to a new poll.

  • Singapore’s new S$20,000 cash declaration rules: What Malaysians need to know

    Singapore has implemented new regulations since May requiring all travellers to declare cash exceeding S$20,000 (RM69...

  • Thursday, not Tuesday: PM Anwar raps home minister for batik blunder in Parliament

    KUALA LUMPUR, July 2 — Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim today admonished Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasut...

  • Reporter Reveals 'Real Anger' From Biden White House Aides After Debate

    They were "shocked" and felt "they had not been told the truth," said Axios' Alex Thompson.

  • Harvard Law Professor Delivers Chilling Prediction After Trump Immunity Ruling

    Laurence Tribe explained what the Supreme Court decision means in "practical purposes" and it's "devastating."

  • High Court says no to Najib’s judicial review bid over ‘house arrest’ call

    KUALA LUMPUR, July 3 — The High Court today dismissed former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s bid to compel the f...

  • Ukraine to be told it is too corrupt to join Nato

    Ukraine will be told it is currently too corrupt to join Nato, in a major blow to Volodymyr Zelensky.

  • Donald Trump is the real President of the USA right now

    Donald Trump can’t believe his luck. Just a few days after Joe Biden seemed to fire himself from his own job live on air during a toe-curling presidential debate, the Supreme Court ruled on Monday that sitting and former presidents of the United States possess a degree of immunity not available to private citizens. In this strange new world, Republicans can now win in televised debates and the courts. Nixon must be rolling in his grave.

  • Russia's war-driven economy is so hot that the World Bank upgraded it to a 'high-income country'

    Russia's trade rebounded by nearly 7% last year, while activities in the financial sector and construction grew by 6.6% and 3.6% respectively.

  • Boris Johnson Makes Dramatic Speech to Stir Tory Election Support in U.K.

    For some Conservative voters in the U.K., it might have been as if all their general election dreams have come true. Former British prime minister Boris Johnson entered the general election race Tuesday night, with a loud, last-minute plea to Tory voters to stay true to their party—even as polls show Rishi Sunak’s government headed for a drubbing at Thursday’s polls, with Labour led by Keir Starmer heading for a reputed landslide.“All this is coming now, this week, this gigantic Labour majority

  • A Biden donor says giving him cash is a waste of time and money if that bad debate showed what Biden's really like

    Investor Whitney Tilson said it didn't make sense to support Biden "because he has almost no chance of beating Trump."

  • Russia missed probably its best opportunity to steamroll Ukraine, war analyst argues

    War expert Mick Ryan says Russia failed to act decisively in the Ukraine war, missing a chance to strike a decisive blow.

  • Russia says it destroys five Ukrainian SU-27 jet fighters at airfield

    Russia said on Tuesday it had destroyed five Ukrainian SU-27 fighter jets with Iskander-M missiles and damaged two more at the Myrhorod airfield in Ukraine's central Poltava region. Ukraine said there had been a strike at the airfield but that Russia was exaggerating the damage caused. Ukraine did not detail exactly what had been damaged.

  • The most immediate threat to China's economy isn't external. It's internal.

    Recent gauges of China's manufacturing activity show export demand, but domestic sentiment is weak.

  • Someone is standing up to Beijing’s ‘Nine Dash Line’ South China Sea land-grab

    Scarborough Shoal is a ring of rocks and reefs 29 miles around that lies within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone in the South China Sea west of Luzon, the Philippines’ biggest island. Unfortunately for the Philippines, the Shoal also lies within the so-called “Nine Dash Line” under which China attempts to claim that it owns more or less the entire South China Sea – in defiance of international law and international court judgement.

  • Gov. Doug Burgum Mocked For Saying Trump Will Only Serve 1 Term If Reelected

    "President Trump, [if] he wins, he serves four years and won't be on the ballot again," the North Dakota governor told Fox News.

  • All change? Labour tipped to oust Tories at UK election

    Britain looks likely to see a change of government this week, swinging leftwards back to the centre ground and the Labour party after 14 years of right-wing Conservative rule.  Voters will elect a new parliament from 7:00 am (0600 GMT) on Thursday, with predictions of a landslide Labour win that would make Keir Starmer prime minister -- 100 years after Ramsay MacDonald became the party's first. "There is more chance of lightning striking twice in the same place... than Rishi Sunak remaining as prime minister," Britain's pre-eminent political polling expert John Curtice told the BBC on Tuesday.Starmer and Conservative leader Sunak have been criss-crossing the country in the final days of a largely lacklustre campaign to try to win over wavering voters.  Many people appear to have long made up their minds, however, with focus on little else other than whether Labour's consistent 20-point lead in the polls for the last two years will translate into a record majority. Prime Minister Sunak on Tuesday insisted that he is "fighting for every vote till the last moment of the campaign", drawing hope from England's last-gasp win in the European football championships.  "It's not over until it's over," Sunak wrote on social media on Sunday night after England's footballers scored a stoppage-time equaliser against Slovakia and then an extra-time winner.Starmer, a staunch Arsenal fan who still plays five-a-side football at 61, is also calling on his team to play until the final whistle, with fears that talk of a Labour "supermajority" could hit turn-out.- Growth -Sunak and the Tories -- another name for the Conservatives -- have been going all out to play upon people's fears, warning of tax rises and weaker national security if they are voted out, in what Labour sees as a desperate last-stand to cling on to power.But in a sign the political landscape has already shifted, it was Starmer, not Sunak, whose views were sought in the aftermath of the far-right win in the first round of the French general election.He has also been asked how he, as the leader of a "progressive" centre-left party, would deal with the possible return of Donald Trump as US president later this year.Attention in the British media is meanwhile mostly on what a Starmer government would look like when the results for the 650-seat parliament start dropping from about 2230 GMT on Thursday into Friday morning.Thursday's vote is Britain's first July election since 1945, when Labour under Clement Attlee defeated the Conservatives of World War II leader Winston Churchill, ushering in a period of transformational social change.Attlee's government created the modern welfare state, including the National Health Service, Britain's most cherished institution after the royal family. Starmer's "change" agenda is not so radical this time around and promises cautious management of the country's economy, as part of a long-term growth plan that includes nursing battered public services back to health."The most important thing is growing the economy and wealth creation," he told The Times in an interview published on Tuesday. "You can talk about public services but if you haven't got your economy working then you can't do that."- 'Run out of road' -With an air of inevitability about a Labour win, Starmer and his colleagues are facing mounting calls and growing expectations to change Britain's flagging fortunes for the better.Economists say anaemic growth should be addressed. Pro-Europeans want Brexit reversed. Everyone wants an end to the sustained squeeze on their finances over the last decade and a half that has tipped more people into poverty."In 2010, when the Conservatives came to power, the UK had 35 foodbanks. Now there are 2,600," Gordon Brown, Labour's last prime minister, wrote in the Daily Mirror on Tuesday.Others want a return of political integrity and stability after a chaotic period of five prime ministers, a succession of scandals and ideological infighting between centrists and right-wingers that shows no sign of abating. Starmer -- the working-class son of a tool maker and a nurse -- has none of the political charisma or popularity of former leader Tony Blair when he ended 18 years of Tory rule in a wave of optimism in 1997. But the former human rights lawyer and chief public prosecutor stands to gain from a country fed up with the Tories, and a feeling of decline rather than improvement."The Conservatives have run out of road. Labour must be given a chance to govern," said a Financial Times editorial Monday.phz/har/bc

  • Only far right can win absolute majority, French PM warns

    The far-right National Rally (RN) is the only party capable of winning an absolute majority in France's legislative elections, Prime Minister Gabriel Attal said Wednesday, urging voters to block their rise to power.An absolute majority of 289 seats is needed in the 577 seat National Assembly for a party to form a government on its own.

  • Biden insists ‘I’m not leaving’ while allies prepare for end of his campaign

    White House denies that the president is confronting the possibility of dropping out

  • Negotiated outcome most likely result of Russia-Ukraine war, major poll says

    In thinktank’s survey of 15 European countries, few respondents believe Ukraine can secure an outright victory